All
Section
Appendix
6.2

Law

Law is a promising baseline for guiding AIs, due to its comprehensiveness and specificity. However, relying solely on the law could still leave many gaps that the AI could exploit, or let them take actions that are morally wrong.

No items found.

Review Questions

What are some features of law that give it an advantage over ethics?

Answer:

Law is a legitimate aggregation of values, time-tested and comprehensive, and can be specific yet adaptable.

View Answer
Hide Answer

What is the difference between rules and standards in law? How might an AI's adherence to the law differ based on whether rules or standards are emphasized?

Answer:

Rules have clear triggers while standards require interpretation. Rules risk being under/over-inclusive but allow predictable control. Standards are flexible but give judges more power over outcomes. An AI following rules might act literally while one applying standards might make more contextual judgments.

View Answer
Hide Answer

What are three limitations of solely relying on law to guide AI behavior?

Answer:

Law is silent on some issues, can be unethical, and may be insufficiently representative of human values.

View Answer
Hide Answer